Showing posts with label basketball. Show all posts
Showing posts with label basketball. Show all posts

Saturday, November 5, 2016

Tarnished Heels -- Chapter Twenty-three

Chapter Twenty-Three
National media attention; the cost of a scandal

            The different athletic/academic scandals at UNC had caused small national ripples at times over the previous three years, but never had any truly moved to the forefront of the national media.  That finally showed signs of changing, however.  The New York Times published an article on the scandal that appeared online late on December 31, 2013, and then in print on New Year’s Day.  BusinessWeek followed with a series of articles that began on January 2.  There was an in-depth CNN report by Sara Ganim on January 7.  Incidentally, Ganim was the reporter who had uncovered many key details during the early stages of the Penn State case involving Jerry Sandusky.  The New York Post contributed a piece on January 11, and then a crippling episode of ESPN’s investigative show “Outside the Lines” aired on January 14, 2014, blatantly calling out UNC for the apparent fraud that benefitted athletes, and the NCAA for refusing to take any action.
            The implications of so much attention from national media sources meant that it might be extremely difficult for the NCAA to ignore the issues going forward.  Why that had even transpired for so long was truly a mystery, especially when considering past similar cases.  Several years earlier the NCAA had ruled that Florida State had been guilty of major violations in a widespread academic fraud case from 2006 and 2007.  An online music class was apparently taught irregularly, a former learning specialist had typed portions of papers for three student-athletes, and answers were provided to an athlete for an online psychology course.  The case involved 61 athletes, all of whose individual records were eventually expunged.  Furthermore, a total of 12 wins by the school’s football team were retroactively erased by the NCAA for the use of ineligible players.  The number of classes and affected student-athletes in FSU’s case paled in comparison to the AFAM fraud at UNC.
            At the University of Georgia in 2003 a former player – Tony Cole – claimed that an assistant coach had paid some of his bills, done schoolwork for him, and taught a sham class on coaching.  Cole said he never attended the class, but along with two other basketball players received an A.  That seemed extremely similar to the AFAM scandal, except for the fact that it was only one class and three student-athletes at Georgia – compared to hundreds of courses and student-athletes at UNC.  The Georgia basketball program self-banned itself from the 2003 postseason, but then the NCAA added further penalties:  the loss of future scholarships, the vacating of numerous wins over a three-year period, and the expunging of players’ records.
            A scandal surfaced at the University of Minnesota in early 1999.  A former basketball office manager said she had written papers for at least 20 men’s basketball players over a period of several years.  Two days after the story first ran, the NCAA suspended four current players.  Following a full investigation a number of violations were uncovered, and the school was ultimately stripped of all postseason awards, titles, personal records, and statistics dating back to the 1993-94 season.  Later, the Big Ten conference vacated the school’s 1997 conference title, and the school also returned 90% of the profits earned by the team during various appearances in the NCAA tournament.  There were stark similarities between Minnesota’s and UNC’s cases.  But once again, the situation in Chapel Hill appeared to dwarf what had happened at the other school.  If the same scrutiny were given to UNC as to Minnesota (a full-fledged, external investigation), the vacated results and titles would be much greater.
* * *
            Often over the past several years fans of UNC had complained that the media and other factions were “out to get” the school, and were determined to have the basketball national championship banners removed.  What those individuals likely did not realize was that the basketball team was a massive part of the school’s image, and people often associated the success of those year-to-year teams with their overall perception of the university.  In essence, when the team did well, in various areas the school also did well.  For example, a March 19, 2009, article on wral.com was titled “Heels merchandise head and shoulders above rest.”  The article stated that the Tar Heel brand name was a money-maker, and had generated $25.9 million for the university, according to a then-recent analysis by Forbes magazine.  Those sales had made UNC the most valuable men’s basketball program in the country.  As a result, it became clear that UNC and its leaders likely weren’t just trying to protect the banners that hung in the rafters of the Dean Smith Center, but also the revenue that poured in due to those teams’ successes. 
            Retailers in Chapel Hill spoke to wral.com about the ease of selling UNC-branded clothing, mugs, and other items.  “I told somebody the other day there’s only four things that people need.  That’s food, gas, shelter and Carolina souvenirs, and we happen to be in the latter part of that, so we’re very fortunate,” said Genny Wrenn, manager of a store on Franklin Street.  Carolina Brewery manager Thomas Transue said his restaurant was usually packed during the NCAA Tournament, especially when UNC was playing.  “There is such a strong background.  We’ve had folks coming in for years for the Tar Heels,” he said. 
            There were other measurable benefits to having a basketball program that accomplished great feats.  Based on a December 19, 2012, article in the News and Observer, the prior year’s profit from the school’s basketball team had been $16.9 million.  It had also ranked number one in a recent ESPN assessment of top 50 college basketball programs based on wins, championships, and lack of NCAA sanctions.  During the 2012 fiscal year, donations to the school’s Ram’s Club, which funded student-athlete scholarships and capital projects, had increased to $33 million. 
            The positive effects of a strong public perception could spread to other areas of the university, as well.  Statistics had long shown that freshman applications to a school often increased following a sports championship – of which UNC had won three since 1992.  Based on data from the school’s own uncnews.unc.edu site, the application rate continued to climb.  The site reported that in the fall of 2013 the university enrolled nearly 4,000 first-year students from a record 30,836 applications.  Furthermore, the school was 9th among leading private and public research universities for the level of federal funding devoted to research and development in all fields.  It was also among the top 100 U.S. colleges and universities awarding undergraduate degrees to minority students, according to a 2011 issue of the magazine Diverse: Issues in Higher Education.  The school ranked 2nd for graduating African-American students majoring in area, ethnic, cultural, gender, and group studies.  Unfortunately, that last statistic might be viewed in a somewhat critical light going forward due to the extensive AFAM scandal.
            How many of those donations, applications, honors and awards were connected to an image carved at least in part by athletes and their successes?  That would be a matter of opinion, obviously, unless one could find specific quotes from people who stated they were influenced by such athletic accomplishments.  The fact that UNC men’s basketball merchandise was the top seller in the entire country, however, spoke to the mindset of influence and desired conformity.  The fact that UNC sold merchandise, received applications, and were given grants was not just beneficial to it as a university and brand.  It also conversely had a negative effect on other area schools – schools that were actually doing things the right way, instead of simply claiming to do so.  Those schools that followed and played by the rules may have lost out on merchandise sales, and may have lost out on potential applications.  And while less likely, it cannot be said for certain that they didn’t lose out on grants and funding from certain entities, as well.
* * *
            Based on the numerous instances of public documents having been withheld, misinformation uncovered, and “no comments” often given, UNC made a conscious choice as to how to approach its problems over the past several years.  Those choices had come at a price – both in terms of reputation, but also one of monetary value.  Some of the figures have been discussed earlier in the book, but when looked at as a whole they become even more daunting.  An article appeared on the online site of Synapse Magazine in mid-November 2013 which gave an in-depth breakdown of some of the tolls incurred by UNC over the past three-plus years.
            Titled “The Cost of a Scandal,” the piece gathered its data from both publicly-released information as well as figures provided by the school itself.  The total amount spent for the academic and athletic portions of the university’s troubles reached nearly five million dollars.  Almost $500,000 was spent on lawyers during the initial 2010 football revelations and the first round of academic issues that arose afterwards.  That bill was picked up by two funds, the article reported.  About $219,000 came from the UNC Foundation, a portion of the University’s endowment that drew its funding entirely from private donations.  Approximately $248,000 of those first legal fees came from the athletic budget, university spokeswoman Karen Moon said.  The athletic budget typically did not set aside funds for unexpected expenses (such as legal fees), according to Martina Ballen, chief financial officer of the school’s athletic department.  She said extra revenue from men’s basketball and football from that year helped offset the costs. 
            Other dollar amounts were related to employee payouts.  When Butch Davis’ contract was terminated by the university, the choice was made to pay him a severance package of $2.7 million – even though wording in his contract suggested that he could have been fired with cause and paid nothing.  Disgraced assistant coach John Blake resigned, yet the university paid him $74,500.  Both of those monetary payouts came from the athletic budget.
            Next would be the fees for various public relations experts.  Those companies and/or individuals were hired at the urging of the school’s Board of Trustees and the UNC System’s Board of Governors.  In former Chancellor Holden Thorp’s own words, “Our board was uneasy about whether we were doing the best things we could in terms of public relations.” That led to the hiring of at least three communication experts, with a combined bill of over $530,000.  Sallie Shuping-Russell, secretary of the university’s Board of Trustees, tried to justify the high costs.  “It was no longer just about the athletics program,” she said.  “It became about the integrity of our school.  We were dealing with a level of issues that we didn’t have internal people to sufficiently handle.  It wasn’t like our internal team was just issuing the news – suddenly, we were the news.”  However, the hiring of the public relations experts didn’t bring about transparency and the truth, but rather a well-crafted message that was passed off to the public.  Many onlookers were intelligent enough to see the scandalous situations for what they truly were, and thus saw through the PR attempts.
            The infamous Martin investigation cost the school over one million dollars, much of which was paid to the Baker Tilly firm.  Even after spending all of that money for months of work, the company was still forced to recant one of its most vital findings when the local News and Observer newspaper showed it to be false.  All of Baker Tilly’s costs were also financed by the UNC Foundation.  All told, about a third of the money spent during the two scandals came from that Foundation.  It was a financial holding tank for the university that primarily funded scholarships, professorships, and fellowships, but in times of controversy the Foundation was said to be able to help with the load.  An issue that remained unaddressed was whether the numerous alumni, outside affiliates, students, and faculty who had donated money were satisfied knowing that part of their contributions had gone not towards the advancement of education, but rather to help pay off the effects (and suspected cover-up) of scandals.
            Hodding Carter, a UNC professor of leadership and public policy, told the magazine that far too often consultants were only hired to support the position of the administration.  “If you’re going to hire outside anything,” he said, “you better be damn well sure that those outsiders are ruthless, unyielding in their demand for information and absolutely committed beyond their paycheck.”  Based on how much information on the scandals those outside entities either missed (or purposely overlooked), it certainly did not appear that they fit the stringent parameters of which Carter referred.
            On the flip side of the coin was Jan Boxill.  The faculty chairwoman of the university had come under heavy fire for her suspected role in tampering with reports in an effort to dissuade the NCAA from returning to campus.  Not surprisingly, she toed the company line when it came to defending the use of extravagant outside sources, saying that external consultants were crucial for attempting to keep a unified faculty.  “I think if we had the faculty running investigations, the situation would have been more contentious and split,” Boxill said.  “It would have divided the faculty.  We wanted to bring consensus.”  To that effect, near-total consensus was exactly what UNC’s leadership got: other than Mary Willingham and Professor Jay Smith, virtually every other faculty member refused to speak out and stand up for what was moral and right.
            With regards to the handling of public relations, Stanley Katz offered a different and more sobering viewpoint.  A professor of public and international affairs at Princeton University, Katz gave his professional opinion that external help was inexcusable for public relations.  “Universities ought to be able to handle their own public relations,” he said.  “If the university sees the problem as a public relations issue, then it isn’t internalizing the fact that there is a problem with the way (the university) handles (itself).”
            Former Chancellor Thorp indicated that the current situation in which the university found itself could have possibly been reached more cheaply and with less turbulence.  Then, almost as a recurring punch line to an overused joke, he ended the article with the very same tired PR message that had been rolled out by university leaders for several years:  “But it was a tough situation, and I think Carolina is in a good position to move forward.”
* * *
The essential (and unanswered) questions:
-- Would the influx of national attention given to UNC’s scandals finally cause the NCAA to take appropriate action?
-- Other schools had been punished by the NCAA for much lesser infractions.  Why had they not shown public outrage over the preferential treatment that UNC seemed to be receiving?
-- How much money had UNC taken in – from merchandise sales, applications, and other sources – as a direct or indirect result from athletic successes that had possibly been built and achieved through fraudulent academic acts?

-- Why weren’t alumni, outside affiliates, students, and faculty who had donated money to the UNC Foundation not showing public displeasure at the arguably moral misuse of their contributions?

Tarnished Heels -- Chapter Twenty-two

Chapter Twenty-Two
NCAA stays away; Nyang’oro indicted; Hairston dismissed

            The final months of 2013 would contain a flurry of articles spanning nearly every aspect of UNC’s multiple scandals.  On September 27 the men’s basketball team began preseason practice.  Both P.J. Hairston and Leslie McDonald were present, but word was circulating that if the season had started that day, neither would be on the court.  It remained to be seen if that would truly be the case once the team played its opening game in six more weeks.  Meanwhile, more news emerged on other fronts.
            An October 7, 2013, article in the News and Observer provided an update on the AFAM department and the students who had been affected by fraudulent classes.  As of the article’s print date, only one student had enrolled in a make-up course and only one alumnus had inquired about the possibility, according to university officials.  UNC spokeswoman Dee Reid said that 46 people were at risk of not graduating unless they completed an extra course.  Reid said she didn’t know what year of study the 46 affected students were in or how many of them were athletes.  The offer of free courses was part of an arrangement the school made with SACS, the accrediting body of the university.  The academic degrees of 384 students and alumni were said to have been affected between 1997 and 2009, according to UNC.  Future data presented by the N&O, however, would show that the numbers were likely much higher: as many as 4,200 students could have ultimately been affected by taking fraudulent courses.
            Of the 384 people officially identified, 80 were current students and 304 were alumni.  There was no mandate for the alumni to return to campus to retake a class, however.  The article said that because university policy required that transcripts be sealed one year after graduation, there would be no way to award credit or a grade for a new class.  The university had said it would cover the cost of the extra courses and textbooks with private funds.  It remained unclear whether more students would feel obligated to do the extra work for a problem that was essentially caused by factions within the university itself.
* * *
            That same day a report came out stating that a longtime UNC tutor had quit, and done so in the form of writing a letter to basketball coach Roy Williams that was published in The Daily Tar Heel.  Jack Halperin’s short message said:  “Roy, after 23 years as an academic tutor, and after going through the devastating football scandal, I am resigning in protest of your disgraceful decision to allow P.J. Hairston to remain on the team.  If I were arrested driving with no license, illegal drugs and a gun in a felon’s car, my employment at this University would end immediately.  Hairston’s DTH quote was, ‘I will play this season.’  Since when does the criminal decide his fate?” 
* * *
            An article appeared on October 11, 2013, on insidehighered.com detailing a new documentary film called “Schooled: The Price of College Sports”.  It was based on the widely read Atlantic article “The Shame of College Sports” by historian Taylor Branch.  Multiple people involved in varying aspects of college sports – both past and present – spoke in the documentary.  Two of particular interest were UNC learning specialist Mary Willingham and News and Observer reporter Dan Kane.
            “It’s the adults that are failing the students,” Willingham said.  She also recounted a sobering conversation with a top UNC athletic official, the article detailed.  The official acknowledged that investing millions to boost the school’s mid-level football team to the elite level in the late-1990’s would mean recruiting academically unprepared students.  “I just felt like I was drowning,” Willingham said of the “drastic drop” in athletes’ academic preparation that followed.  Some students who had been recruited couldn’t even read, and she recalled three in particular with whom she had to work on “letters and sounds.”
            When the article (based on the corresponding documentary) mentioned the fraudulent AFAM classes which displayed multiple signs of being a vehicle to keep athletes eligible, it observed that the NCAA declined to investigate UNC because athletes were not the sole beneficiaries of the classes.  “If the NCAA doesn’t want to look at this,” Dan Kane said, “you could argue they just sent a message to everyone across the county.”  He was likely referring to a “blueprint” that other schools could follow if they wanted to provide impermissible academic assistance to their athletes without garnering unwanted attention from the Athletic Association.
* * *
            UNC began its basketball season on November 8, 2013, and both P.J. Hairston and Leslie McDonald sat out the contest.  No official word was given for their absence other than there being “eligibility concerns.”  There was another equally big story on that day as well.  A News and Observer article was released that stated the NCAA was unlikely to punish the school for the widespread academic fraud in its AFAM department. 
            Information had been discovered once again through public records requests by the newspaper that had finally been filled.  According to the N&O, newly released email correspondence revealed that the NCAA still did not see the school’s athletic/academic fraud as a concern.  Writer Dan Kane said that in late September, Vince Ille, a UNC senior athletic official who had first been discussed in Chapter Eleven of this book, asked the NCAA to confirm that it had no plans to further investigate the fraud.  “It is my understanding that, based on the available information, no additional investigation regarding these issues is being contemplated by the NCAA enforcement staff, nor does the staff believe that any modification of the infractions case that was complete on March 12, 2012 is necessary,” Ille wrote.  “Can you please confirm or correct this assessment?”  Less than an hour later, Mike Zonder, the NCAA’s associate director for enforcement, responded:  “You are correct in your assessment regarding the situation involving the AFAM department.”
            Zonder and NCAA President Mark Emmert did not respond to interview requests from the N&O.  A spokeswoman for the NCAA, Emily James Potter, said in a short statement that Zonder’s email was “correct.”  Ille and other UNC officials also declined to be interviewed.  An ambiguity was where Ille had initially gotten the impression that led to his email to Zonder: that it has been his “understanding” that nothing additional would happen to the university.  One possibility for that impression (which was hinted at in the article) could have come from Jackie Thurnes, Ille’s former co-worker when he was at the University of Illinois.  After working with Ille on that collegiate campus, Thurnes would leave Illinois to become an enforcement official with the NCAA.
            Overall, the article’s effect on the watchful public was one of stunned disbelief.  Over a year earlier in September of 2012, UNC officials had released a statement saying that the NCAA had thus far found no evidence of violations.  A vast amount of incriminating news had emerged since then, however, detailing multiple connections between athletics and the academic fraud.  So it was no surprise that onlookers were left dumbfounded by the NCAA’s continued indifference to the events in Chapel Hill.
* * *
            It was detailed in an earlier chapter the vast amount of money UNC had spent on outside public relations assistance – a known total in the half-million dollar range.  With that in mind, an early-November employment announcement from the school made an ironic bit of sense.  A release from wral.com on November 11, 2013, said that Joel Curran, a senior executive in a public relations agency and fittingly an alumnus of UNC, had been named the school’s first vice chancellor for communications and public affairs.  Curran was the managing director of the New York office for MSLGROUP, described in part as the world’s fourth largest public relations and engagement agency.  The news release added that he had worked at public relations agencies across the country.  Some people in social media speculated that if UNC felt the need to continue to spin stories and craft a certain message, they might as well hire someone full-time to help with that task.
* * *
            On December 2, 2013, an Orange County grand jury indicted former AFAM department chairman Julius Nyang’oro on a charge of obtaining property by false pretense.  More importantly, his lawyer – Bill Thomas of Durham – said that his client intended to fight the charge filed against him.  “Dr. Nyang’oro is presumed to be innocent under our law,” Thomas said.  “There’s been one side of this story that has been put forth in the press, but he’s going to have an opportunity to present his side.  We intend to present his case in court.  He is going to contest these charges.”  Those statements held some large ramifications, as Nyang’oro could possibly divulge a massive amount of as-yet-unreleased information about the AFAM scandal if put on the stand.
            An article on December 3, 2013, by the News and Observer also had further insight from Jim Woodall, the Orange County District Attorney.  Woodall had indicated that a second individual could face charges in the case, but he would only say that person was not a current UNC employee.  Widespread speculation was that he was referring to Deborah Crowder, the longtime AFAM department manager who had also been extremely close to factions within the school’s men’s basketball program.  Crowder had retired in 2009.
* * *
            Yet another embarrassing episode would hit the school’s basketball program a few days later.  On December 6, 2013, a former UNC player was found to have marijuana and drug paraphernalia inside a house he had been renting from head basketball coach Roy Williams.  According to a follow-up article from the News & Observer on December 13, Will Graves was the former player in question.  Police had found 4.4 grams of marijuana, eight marijuana seeds, three blunts, and two “burnt marijuana blunts” inside the rented house.
            Steve Kirschner, a UNC athletics department spokesman, said Graves had been renting the house from Williams while Graves took classes at UNC during the fall semester.  Graves had played for the Tar Heels from 2007 through 2010, but had actually been kicked off of the team by Williams for a violation of team rules.  Despite that prior conflict, Graves had been serving as a part-time video coordinator for the men’s basketball team at the time of the drug discovery.  Property tax records showed that the house had an assessed value of over $600,000.  In a separate article, Kirschner had told the Associated Press that Williams had allowed people to stay at the home periodically.
* * *
            On December 18, 2013, basketball player Leslie McDonald was cleared by the NCAA to return to the team.  He had missed a total of nine games due to receiving impermissible benefits.  Among them had been the use of cars associated with Haydn Thomas, the use of a custom mouth guard, and also an iPhone.  He was ordered to repay $1,783 to a charity of his choice before the end of the regular season. 
            Fellow player P.J. Hairston was not as fortunate.  The school announced two days later that Hairston would not return to the court that season, as the university had decided against seeking his reinstatement from the NCAA.  UNC Athletic Director Bubba Cunningham gave more insight into the matter in a December 20, 2013, News and Observer article.  “We’ve all been hopeful the entire time that he would be able to play again,” Cunningham said.  “But by the time we gathered all the information and worked with the NCAA, it just wasn’t there.”  Cunningham declined to detail the exact monetary value of the impermissible benefits Hairston had received. 
            When news began to spread that the school hadn’t even asked the NCAA to look at Hairston’s situation, many in social media began to speculate whether there was a deeper reason for that inaction by the university.  Some wondered if the purpose was to keep from having to release information to the NCAA that might have uncovered even more issues within the basketball program.  Or, in Hairston’s specific case, might have spanned back to prior seasons and forced the vacating of wins.
            Hairston’s family released a statement in which it criticized UNC’s decision not to seek reinstatement, the N&O article reported.  “We are displeased with the University of North Carolina’s decision not to submit the necessary paperwork to the NCAA requesting to have P.J. reinstated,” the statement read.  “This process has been long, and for (it) to end without having a final decision from the governing body is a shame.”
            The Associated Press had earlier reported that Bill Thomas, a Durham lawyer representing Haydn Thomas, said his client had met with school officials in early December for “an in-depth interview… to clear up any misconceptions about the relationship between Haydn Thomas and Mr. Hairston.”  As an interesting and somewhat odd side note, Bill Thomas was also the lawyer representing former AFAM chairman Julius Nyang’oro in his grand jury case.
            Not really mentioned by the media at that time, but still an issue of great importance, was the school’s ongoing NCAA probation.  Athletics Director Bubba Cunningham had made the following statement in early 2013 when discussing the release of the Martin report:  “There’s no denying that we’ve got major violations and we’re on probation.  We didn’t go to a bowl game, and we’re under the repeat violator clause for the next five years.”  The infractions incurred by McDonald and Hairston would clearly appear to be a violation of the school’s probation.  Once again, where was the NCAA?
* * *
            As December would near its end, an article appeared on the website bleacherreport.com titled “Inside Roy Williams’ Most Trying Season.”  It talked of the effects the various scandals had had on the 63-year-old coach, with Williams saying, “I never in my life thought I’d have these kind of things happen.  It’s cast a light on our program that I don’t like, and it’s cast a light on me that I don’t like at all.”  Scott Williams, the coach’s son, actually had some very telling comments in the article – some of which could have even been considered  Freudian slips.  “It’s not that Carolina’s record is spotless,” the younger Williams said.  “No one’s record is spotless.  But in the past it was much easier to get things taken care of and not have everything play out in such a public forum.”
* * *
            With 2013 drawing to a close, it had ultimately proven to be another year of scandals surrounding the athletic/academic infrastructure of UNC, and another year of the university’s leadership refusing to come clean and show full transparency.  Public records and documents continued to be withheld from the media, which only prolonged the likely eventual emergence of more damning information in the future.  As it was, the tide would take a major turn when the calendar rolled over to 2014.  Once relegated to the local North Carolina sports and academic scenes, the story garnered national attention in a big way as the New Year began.
* * *
The essential (and unanswered) questions:
-- Even with a prodigious amount of new and incriminating evidence that clearly suggested widespread athletic/academic fraud, why was the scandal at UNC still not a concern to the NCAA as 2013 came to an end?
-- Did UNC not seek reinstatement for P.J. Hairston in an attempt to specifically avoid further scrutiny from the NCAA – scrutiny which might have spilled over to other players and/or earlier athletic seasons?

-- Considering the fact that UNC was already on probation following its multiple infractions from several years earlier, why didn’t the impermissible benefits received by McDonald and Hairston trigger immediate repercussions from the NCAA?

Tarnished Heels -- Chapter Twenty

Chapter Twenty
Jan Boxill and athletic-minded edits to a faculty report

            As discussed in Chapter Eighteen, wording in a UNC internal academic report released in late July of 2012 had been changed at the last minute prior to its release.  The changes were initiated by Jan Boxill, chairwoman of the school’s Faculty Executive Committee.  When the News and Observer first reported on the changes in mid-May of 2013, some details were lacking as to why the edits were requested.  However, newly released correspondence led to a new N&O article on July 20, 2013.  The apparent motivation behind Boxill’s requests seemed to fall in line with the university’s perceived “athletics first” mantra that had become apparent over the years of scandals.
            The July 20 article, penned by Dan Kane, focused on emails between faculty leaders at the school.  The specific requested change by Boxill was in reference to Deborah Crowder, the long-time administrative assistant in the scandalous AFAM department who also had very close ties to the men’s basketball program.  With regards to why Crowder’s name and specific connections to basketball were being eliminated from the report, a past email from Boxill to the faculty authors of the special internal probe stated:  “The worry is that this could further raise NCAA issues and that is not the intention.”  Essentially, it appeared as if the school (and its leaders) were specifically trying to avoid more attention from the NCAA, and they felt that if too many specifics were included in the report, then the Athletic Association might return and open a new investigation.
            John Thelin, an education professor at the University of Kentucky and author of “Games Colleges Play,” indicated that rewriting a sentence that carried the suggestion of an athletic motive behind the scandal should not have been the mission of a member of the faculty.  “The faculty committee should not anticipate the audience or implications,” Thelin told the newspaper, “but rather fulfill the charge they undertook.”  Jay Smith, the UNC history professor who had long been one of the athletic/academic scandal’s most vocal critics, said of Boxill’s meddling:  “It seems consistent with what I have taken to be the university’s strategy all along, which is they wanted to come up with findings that seemed frank and candid, but which also carefully exclude any further NCAA investigation.”  That would be an important strategy indeed, as the article noted that the NCAA typically did not involve itself in academic fraud cases unless there was an intent to assist athletes above other students.
            Oddly, the change in the faculty report was made after Boxill and several committee members had praised previous drafts, Kane wrote.  Boxill said in an earlier email to the N&O that some faculty committee members objected to describing Crowder as “extremely close” to athletic personnel.  Boxill called it “vague without definite boundaries.”  Seven of the faculty members on the committee in a position to review the report said they did not make the suggestion; the other five who were not authors of the report could not be reached.  Boxill claimed others on the committee had suggested the change, but who those people were remained unknown.  Boxill did not respond to interview requests from the N&O for the July 20 article.
            Along with Crowder having many earlier-documented ties to athletics, Boxill herself was in a similar position.  She was a former women’s basketball coach at another university, and had worked in broadcasting with UNC’s women’s basketball team.  She also had extensive academic ties to UNC athletics.  For over 20 years – starting in 1988 – Boxill had been an Academic Counselor in the Student Athlete Development Center.  Other positions she had held in that Athlete Development Center in the past included the Learning Skills Coordinator, the Freshmen Academic Success Program Coordinator, the Tutor Coordinator/Supervisor, and the Intern Supervisor.  This begged a clear and obvious question: had Boxill used her position as chairwoman of the school’s Faculty Executive Committee to influence the 2012 internal report in an attempt to protect athletics?  Boxill was the first non-tenured faculty member elected to the chairman/woman’s post.  Ironically, the subject of one of her philosophy courses at UNC was ethics in sports.
* * *
            The authors of the 2012 faculty report were Laurie Maffly-Kipp, Steven Bachenheimer, and Michael Gerhardt.  According to the N&O’s article, correspondence among the three showed that they were worried that Boxill would try and dilute the findings of the report prior to its release.  They sent drafts to her in Portable Document Formats (PDFs) so she could not easily alter them.  After a draft of the report had been discussed in a Faculty Executive Council meeting, Gerhardt wrote in an email: “It seems to me that we might need to tell Jan that there is a line we hope she does not cross.”  Maffly-Kipp also questioned the need for the late changes.  “Why is it a good thing to remove Deborah Crowder’s name from the report?” she asked.  “The fact is, she was close to people in athletics.”  Gerhardt, a law professor, wrote:  “(Boxill) is free to disagree with the report as anyone is, but i (sic) cannot believe she has the authority to change what it says.  Indeed, apart from her lack of authority to do this, it strikes me as very poor political judgment.  Just imagine what the papers will do with that.”
* * *
            An editorial was released in the News and Observer on July 24, 2013, by staff writer Luke DeCock.  Following the story of Boxill’s role in the final faculty report, the editorial was largely directed at the faculty in general.  DeCock said that one of the most surprising developments in the three years since the school had admitted academic fraud was the role the faculty had played.  Specifically, “the faculty has been almost entirely absent.  Complicit, by collective silence.  Complicit, in the case of Jan Boxill, by action.”
            When referencing past half-hearted attempts at reform by the university, the editorial mentioned Thorp and his commission of the Martin report.  “Jim Martin, an honorable, respected, dignified man of distinguished service to the state of North Carolina, ended up the figurehead of a report that posed few legitimate questions and answered fewer, a whitewash.”  At the same time, however, DeCock said the faculty’s silence along the way may have been somewhat understandable – if not justifiable.  “It’s not hard to understand why some faculty may not have thought it worth speaking out.  Many had confidence in Thorp, a longtime colleague, and taking a more aggressive public stance would have meant crossing him.”  A year earlier while speaking at a forum on the future of intercollegiate athletics in Chapel Hill, Professor Hodding Carter III made reference to faculty inaction.  “As far as I can see, on one campus after another, the silence of the faculty is very much the silence of the lambs,” Carter had said, “allowing the slaughter of the integrity of the institutions they serve to go forward.”  As was widely known at the time of DeCock’s editorial, essentially the only two UNC faculty members who had shown any sort of displeasure in the university’s handling of the scandal were Jay Smith and Mary Willingham. 
            The piece ended by referencing the late Bill Friday, a long-time academic leader in the state who was associated with UNC.  Also included was a pointed condemnation of the school’s storied reputation:  “Perhaps the disclosure of Boxill’s role will serve as a catalyst for more decisive action on the part of her colleagues, because North Carolina is making a mockery of Friday’s dream.  That’s no way to honor the legacy of a man who deserves better, or a school that once stood for something more.”
* * *
            In an interview almost 10 days later, Boxill finally spoke about the changes she had made to the 2012 faculty report.  In a July 30, 2013, article in the News and Observer, Boxill said her suggestion for a revision came from other committee members who, during a session to review the draft, did not like the phrase “athletic supporter” (when referencing Deborah Crowder), partly because of its alternative meaning as a “jock strap”.  Boxill said she did not remember which members had uttered the concerns in the committee meeting.  As noted in Kane’s article from a week and a half earlier, all of the members he had spoken to had denied making the suggested changes.  Not surprisingly, also left unaddressed in the new article was why Crowder’s name had been completely removed from the report.
* * *
The essential (and unanswered) questions:
-- Did Jan Boxill change the wording of a 2012 academic report with the specific intent of trying to keep the NCAA from returning to campus?

-- Given Boxill’s close ties to UNC athletics for over 20 years, had she used her then-current position of leadership to purposely try and shield the school’s athletic programs from additional scrutiny? 

Friday, November 4, 2016

Tarnished Heels - Chapter Eighteen

Chapter Eighteen
Carol Folt; Jan Boxill; James Moeser;
Nyang’oro and Crowder emails; public relations firms


            As the date drew nearer when Holden Thorp would be stepping down as Chancellor, his eventual replacement was announced.  Carol Folt, an environmental scientist who had worked for 30 years at Dartmouth College (including nearly a year as interim president), was tabbed to take over UNC’s top spot.  Based on quotes and details in an April 13, 2013, News and Observer article covering a reception held in Folt’s honor, she indicated that she was excited about her new duties.  “It’s the honor of a lifetime,” she said.  “I just can’t tell you how it feels.  It’s a little bit of a dream state.”  Folt said she had been on a tour of the campus, and that she and her husband had caught “Tar Heel fever” when they attended a Duke-UNC basketball game the previous month.  She did, however, allude to some of the issues that had plagued the school over the prior several years.  Referencing perspective, optimism, and opportunity, she said: “That’s what will carry us through the tough times.”  Indeed, she wouldn’t have long to wait for more “tough times” to surface.
* * *
            The previous chapter discussed requests for public documents, and the often difficult obstacles the media had faced to get many of its requests fulfilled.  Several documents were released in May, however, and they led to more discoveries of possible improprieties.  According to a May 18, 2013, article in the News and Observer, a key UNC report from a year earlier had purposely omitted substantial information that would have painted athletics in a much more critical light.
            In July of 2012 a special faculty report on the academic fraud (initially discussed in Chapter Eight) suggested that academic counselors may have steered athletes to fraudulent classes in the AFAM department.  A request by the newspaper for emails and other correspondence related to that report had finally been filled by the school, and the details revealed some interesting final-day edits.  Earlier drafts of the report (but not the final version) had specifically mentioned Deborah Crowder, the former assistant in the AFAM department, and also noted her connections to athletics. 
            The earlier draft had the following statement:  “Although we may never know for certain, the involvement of Debbie Crowder seems to have been that of an athletic supporter who managed to use the system to ‘help’ players; she was extremely close to personnel in athletics.”   However, documentation showed that Jan Boxill, chairwoman of the school’s Faculty Executive Committee and also a former academic counselor for athletes, wanted the statement cut because in her opinion it amounted to hearsay.  She told the authors of the report that other professors, whom she did not identify, raised that concern.  The final version did in fact make a change and read as follows:  “Although we may never know for certain, it was our impression from multiple interviews that a department staff member managed to use the system to help players by directing them to enroll in courses in the African and Afro-American Studies department that turned out to be aberrant or irregularly taught.”  The final version had no specific mention of Crowder, and more importantly no mention of her being “extremely close” to athletics. 
            The May 18 N&O article went on to make it clear that the information about Crowder was not hearsay.  Crowder’s ties to the athletics department had been reported by the paper in June of 2012, and were also later acknowledged in the Martin report.  As mentioned earlier, Martin never interviewed Crowder.  He had, however, received both versions of the faculty report in question.  Why no mention of Boxill’s requested edit was ever made in his report is unknown.  Furthermore, other records showed numerous bogus classes that appeared to have been set up by Crowder.  Athletes accounted for all but eight of the 56 students enrolled in nine specific classes.  Those enrollments included 31 football players and eight basketball players, all of which further cemented the “not hearsay” stance of the newspaper.  It was extremely unclear, therefore, why the authors of the faculty report gave in to Boxill’s request.  More details on the matter would surface several months in the future, however.
* * *
            As Holden Thorp’s tenure as chancellor continued to draw to its end, more controversy arose, but this time by his own doing.  He had said in April of 2013 that he felt college presidents had pressing demands and therefore should leave sports to athletics directors.  That rubbed many people the wrong way, especially at UNC.  Hodding Carter III was a UNC professor and former Knight Foundation president.  The goal of the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics was to ensure that intercollegiate athletics programs operated within the educational mission of their colleges and universities.  In a May 19, 2013, N&O article, Carter acknowledged that college sports can take a leader down fast, but said that Thorp’s proposal was way off base.  “You really have got to get control of (big-time college sports), but you don’t get control of it by letting the guy who raised Godzilla become the person who now is supposed to supervise Godzilla, and that’s what the athletic directors are, and the conference guys.”
            Thorp indicated that he knew his suggestion would cause waves.  “Bill Friday’s ghost and Hodding Carter and all those people are ready to kill me,” he said.  “They don’t admit that their presidential control idea didn’t work.”  It certainly hadn’t worked in the case of Thorp, the newspaper wrote, who said he took the job with no idea about the athletics minefield ahead.  Too often, Thorp said, he found himself in front of microphones trying to explain the various scandals and pledging to fix them. 
            Looking back, Thorp said he would have done some things differently.  “But it’s always easy to see those things at the end,” he said.  “It’s real easy to look at somebody else’s crisis and know what to do.  It’s a whole different deal when you have a big bureaucratic organization, trying to make quick decisions and getting people on board.”  And “a big bureaucratic organization” was a good analogy for UNC’s leadership over the previous three years of problems.
            The academic scandal in the African Studies department was perhaps the most embarrassing episode to Thorp, but it did have one good result, he said: that a myth had been deconstructed.  “It was a failure of lots of people over a lot of years to detect it,” he said.  “I think that was fueled by this notion that these kinds of things didn’t happen here.”  As for Carol Folt, the woman who would be taking over his position in a couple of months, Thorp had a specific suggestion for her:  Watch the TV drama “Friday Night Lights.”  Thorp said he wished he had watched it five years ago, because an education about athletics would have come in handy.
* * *
During this same timeframe Holden Thorp’s predecessor also spoke up.  James Moeser was chancellor at the school from 2000 to 2008, which incidentally happened to be some of the prime years of the athletic/academic scandal.  Displaying an obstinate loyalty to his former employer, Moeser voiced his displeasure over the media’s coverage of the academic scandal that had involved countless UNC athletes.
            In a mid-May interview in the Chapel Hill Magazine, Moeser said: “I’m really angry about (the media).  I think they target people, and they take pleasure in bringing people down.  I think their real goal here was to remove banners from the Smith Center.”  As the complaints were seemingly directed at the Raleigh News and Observer, which had been unyielding in its coverage of UNC’s various athletic scandals over the previous three years, Moeser’s interview was given attention in a May 20, 2013, article by the newspaper.  The remarks were part of a short article in which Moeser defended “The Carolina Way,” wrote reporter Dan Kane.  That term had become a motto for the university and had formally been a source of pride and chest-thumping from both its alums and nonaffiliated sports fans.  It had recently taken a beating amid the various scandals, however.
            When Moeser referred to the “banners” in the Smith Center, he was undoubtedly talking about the three National Championships that were won by the men’s basketball teams – teams which featured numerous players who majored in an African and Afro-American Studies department that had been proven to be rampant with academic fraud.  Despite the apparently obvious connections between those championships and the proven bogus classes and degrees, Moeser seemed more concerned with defending an ideal.  “I think (the media) has really put a target on the university,” Moeser had told the Chapel Hill Magazine, “and they’ve treated The Carolina Way in a very cynical fashion, trashing it, really, and indicating The Carolina Way was always just a fiction, a façade we put in front of misbehavior.  I really resent that.  I think The Carolina Way is genuine, I think it’s real.” 
            John Drescher, executive editor of the N&O, disputed Moeser’s take on the media coverage.  He provided several quotes for Kane’s article, and would follow up with an editorial the next day.  In Kane’s May 20 piece, Drescher said, “We weren’t trying to get anybody, but we were trying to get to the bottom of what happened at UNC.  Most of our readers understood that and appreciate the digging we did.”  Others in the media also supported the N&O’s work.  John Robinson, the former editor of The (Greensboro) News & Record, wrote in his blog, “Media disrupted,” that Moeser didn’t understand the media’s job in an open society.  “What actually has happened is that the N&O discovered some rot in the internal workings at UNC in athletics and academia and, like an infection in the body, you have to keep going after it to get rid of it all,” Robinson wrote.  “That’s what the N&O has done and is still doing.”
            Even some of the faculty at the university said Moeser’s remarks were misguided, Kane’s article stated.  Michael Hunt, a history professor emeritus, said Moeser may have been reacting to the criticism leveled by rival fans.  “He may be reflecting the embattled feeling that the administrators are feeling,” Hunt said.  “The problem is they are dragging this out, and I don’t think anybody is saying – I haven’t heard a word saying – ‘Oh, the N&O’s persecuting Chapel Hill.’ Nobody is saying that except for the people who are trying to keep the lid on.”  Moeser himself could not be reached for comment.
            A scathing and direct editorial by executive editor John Drescher came out a day later.  In it he countered Moeser, and said the former chancellor had taken up a tactic usually preferred by losing politicians: saying “they’re out to get us.”  When responding to the accusation that the media was trying to bring people (and banners) down, Drescher had this to say: “Moeser’s wrong, obviously.  If the media were any good at targeting people, they would have targeted him.  His successor, Holden Thorp, took over before the scandals broke and ended up taking the heat (and the fall) for problems that festered under his predecessor.”
            Drescher went on to allude to the “Carolina Way” that Moeser had opined about.  “UNC’s reputation for academic quality and aboveboard athletics has taken a hard hit.  The damage has been made far worse by the failure of university leaders to admit problems and search relentlessly for where the trouble began and where it spread.”  Finally, the executive editor reached the heart of the matter by way of a statement that could have been said about countless UNC, Board of Trustees, and Board of Governors leaders over the past three years:  “But what is Moeser angry about?  Not about what happened or how it has been handled.  He’s angry about what got reported.  He thinks reporting that seeks to find the extent of the problems is a mean-spirited effort to strip a proud university of its greatest athletic laurels, the banners from its national men’s basketball titles.  No, it’s an attempt to do what universities also should do: Seek the truth.”
* * *
More damaging information would surface less than three weeks later, and again it was due to the school (finally) releasing public information that they had long tried to conceal.  A set of newly released emails was the focus of a June 8, 2013, article in the News and Observer, and a key confirmation was the very close relationship former AFAM chairman Julius Nyang’oro had with the program that tutored athletes.  The emails in question were released by the university as part of a public records request that had been filed nearly a year earlier.  Inexplicably, none of the details within the correspondence had shown up in the numerous investigations conducted since the school confirmed the existence of the fraudulent courses in May 2012, the paper wrote.  That was once again proof that Martin and Baker Tilley either never checked the emails of Nyang’oro and Crowder, or that the emails were checked and summarily ignored.
UNC Chancellor Holden Thorp and other officials had long said that the Academic Support Program for Student Athletes had not collaborated with anyone in the AFAM department to create the classes that helped to keep athletes eligible to play sports.  Some of the emails strongly suggested otherwise.  One of the exchanges was between Nyang’oro and Jaimie Lee, an academic counselor for athletes.  “I failed to mention yesterday that Swahili 403 last summer was offered as a research paper course,” wrote Lee.  “I meant to (ask), do you think this may happen again in the future?? If not the summer, maybe the fall?”  To which Nyang’oro responded:  “Driving a hard bargain; should have known… :) Will have to think about this, but talk to me….”  Nyang’oro did not schedule the Swahili class, but he did create another one for the summer.  Later that day he emailed Lee informing her of the new class.  Those discussed courses had shown up as ones that should have been taught lecture-style, but had instead been turned into “paper” classes that only required a term paper at the end.
One of the university’s long-standing talking points was that non-athletes took the fraudulent classes as well, which should keep the scandal out of the NCAA’s realm.  School officials said that it wasn’t only athletes who benefitted from the bogus classes.  However, other parts of the email records may have provided a clue as to why non-athletes were in some of the classes.  In early 2005, administrative assistant Deborah Crowder raised concerns that too many students were seeking to enroll in independent studies within her department.  She had told one advising official that word about the department’s independent studies “had sort of gotten into the frat circuit.”  That would seem to imply that the preference was for the courses to be reserved for a very specific subset of UNC’s student population, because as the records showed, the largest percentage taking the courses was athletes.  Considering Crowder’s close ties to athletics (and especially the men’s basketball program), the emails show the distinct possibility that “regular” students signed up for multiple fraudulent AFAM courses against the preferences of athletes at UNC.
            As usual, school officials largely chose to avoid the newly uncovered revelations.  Attempts by the N&O to reach Thorp and Karen Gil, dean of the College of Arts & Sciences (which oversaw advising and the African Studies department), were unsuccessful.  A UNC spokeswoman, Karen Moon, said the newly released correspondence contained no “new information” about the Academic Support Program for Athletes.  But Peter Hans, the chairman of the UNC System Board of Governors, disagreed.  “This is additional confirmation that there was far too cozy a relationship between the academic advisers in the athletic department and Nyang’oro and Crowder,” Hans said.
            Jaimie Lee still worked for the school’s support program at the time of the article, but could not be reached for comment.  Like Deborah Crowder, Lee also had interesting connections.  Before joining UNC as a counselor, she worked for a charitable nonprofit founded by former UNC basketball players, the newspaper reported. 
            The new emails also showed that a tutor, Suzanne Dirr, had drawn up “topic” papers for athletes that were virtual outlines of papers they would have to write for classes.  Interestingly, Dirr submitted her suggested topics to Crowder for approval – despite the fact that Crowder was not a faculty member, but only an administrative assistant.  Crowder’s importance to the AFAM department (and the UNC athletic infrastructure) continued to become more and more evident with each new set of released information.  Dirr died in 2008; Crowder continued to decline numerous requests for interviews.
            Madeline Levine, a former interim dean of the College of Arts & Sciences, said she was appalled to see how much work the tutors had done for the athletes in those classes.  “It looks really corrupt, academically corrupt, to me,” said Levine, who is now retired.  She was also troubled by the tone of the emails between Nyang’oro and various academic counselors.  Levine said that while some of it might have been in jest, it suggested a relationship in which Nyang’oro was doing favors for the counselors.  In one email from September 2009, Cynthia Reynolds, a former associate director who oversaw academic support for football players, told Nyang’oro in an email that “I hear you are doing me a big favor this semester and that I should be bringing you lots of gifts and cash???????”  She also suggested that she and Nyang’oro talk about students’ assignments via “phone call, meeting or drinks, whichever you prefer.” 
            The article reported that on three occasions the records showed that Nyang’oro and his family were offered football tickets and food.  In one email, Reynolds told the former AFAM chairman he would be “guest coaching,” which meant that he could watch the game with the team on the sidelines.  Reynolds left the program in 2010.  An earlier chapter recounted her claim that she had been the victim of age discrimination.  She could not be reached for the article.
            The “no comment” approach continued to be the status quo, as was the practice of dodging questions by university officials.  Beth Bridger, who replaced Reynolds and also showed up in emails, could not be reached for comment.  UNC spokeswoman Karen Moon would not specify who among the various investigators into the academic fraud scandal had received the Crowder and Nyang’oro correspondence given to the News and Observer.  Moon said it was “considered during past investigations, in which the university cooperated fully.”  She also did not explain why it took nearly a year to produce the emails for the N&O.
            Perhaps the most important aspect of the new emails was that they did not represent the entire record.  Karen Moon said other correspondence had been withheld because of student privacy concerns or because it was a personnel matter.  The university could have released additional correspondence with redactions to protect student identities, the newspaper pointed out, or UNC could make the personnel information public under a provision in state law that allowed its release to protect the integrity of the institution. The school chose to not make those efforts, however.  That was likely as telling as the actual emails that were released.
* * *
            Signs had long pointed to a unified “public relations” front by the school, as officials associated with UNC (and even entities such as the System’s Board of Governors) had parroted some of the same catch phrases when commenting on the athletic/academic scandals.  An article published by the News and Observer on June 8, 2013, finally gave some clear evidence as to why those talking points had been so similar.  Public documents that had been released showed that there had been a dedicated PR and communications effort over the previous two years that had cost the university more than $500,000.
            The breakdown of those bills was as follows:  The Fleishman-Hillard firm received $367,000 for 22 months of work; Doug Sosnik, an NBA consultant, received $144,000 for 10 months’ work; and Sheehan Associates of Washington, D.C., received nearly $20,000 for work performed on “two occasions,” a university official said.  As was the case with the nearly one million dollars that was paid to the Baker Tilley firm during the Martin investigation, the university’s privately funded foundation paid for all of those PR costs.
            Some of the specific correspondence between Sosnik and the university was especially revealing.  A former counselor to President Bill Clinton during the Monica Lewinsky embarrassment, the key message Sosnik wanted reinforced at UNC was that the school’s scandal was in the past; the university had made reforms and would become stronger as a result.  Records also showed that UNC administrators, with the help of Sosnik and a member of Fleishman-Hillard, fought back when Mary Willingham told the News and Observer that school staff had used no-show classes to keep athletes eligible.  The school administrators and public relations consultants reviewed and offered edits to a letter to the N&O editorial page written by Steve Kirschner, an athletics department spokesman.  The letter sought to refute Willingham’s claims.  Furthermore, some of the correspondence showed that UNC trustee Don Curtis and Athletics Director Bubba Cunningham didn’t think the NCAA would dig into the academic fraud after former Governor Jim Martin’s investigation concluded that it was an academic scandal and not an athletic scandal.
* * *
            According to a June 20, 2013, article in the News and Observer, UNC was handed down a lenient response from the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges (SACS), which had earlier been on campus following the revelation of academic fraud within the AFAM department.  It was announced that the school would be monitored in the future, but not sanctioned.  Other details were that 384 students who took fraudulent classes from 1997 to 2009 would be given the opportunity to “make whole” their academic degrees.  Specific information regarding the method of completing those degrees was said to be forthcoming.
            Some on campus were appalled by the lack of action by the accrediting agency, the paper noted.  “It’s amazing.  I guess the flagship gets off the hook,” said Mary Willingham, the UNC reading specialist who used to work with athletes and who had been outspoken about the problems at the school.  “For me, it’s getting to the point where power is so much more important than justice.”
* * *
            As the month of June slowly came to an end, one more important article was released regarding the academic situation at UNC.  A June 29, 2013, piece by N&O reporter Dan Kane focused on the academic performance by the school’s athletes, and the stark drop that had happened over the previous several years.  According to recent academic progress statistics from the NCAA, the paper reported, UNC’s men’s basketball team – at one point the best in the Atlantic Coast Conference with a near perfect Academic Progress Rate (APR) score – had fallen to eighth place.  The school’s football team had recently been just a few academic points away from losing postseason eligibility.  Both teams had just scored their all-time lows on the APR.  UNC Athletics Director Bubba Cunningham and other officials declined to be interviewed for the article.  Not surprisingly, the years that UNC’s basketball and football teams scored well on the APR were ones in which athletes had been taking dozens of fraudulent classes within the AFAM department.  With that in mind, it could hardly be considered an unexpected coincidence that the APR score dropped following the exposure of the university’s athletic/academic scandal.
* * *
The essential (and unanswered) questions:
-- Why did the faculty authors of a July 2012 report allow their wording (in reference to Deborah Crowder) to be changed?
-- Other than free tickets and food, did Julius Nyang’oro receive any other gifts from athletic personnel in exchange for academic favors?
-- Why would Crowder be concerned that frat students were signing up for AFAM independent studies courses?
-- Why did athletic tutor Suzanne Dirr submit paper topics directly to Crowder – who wasn’t even a faculty member?
-- Why did none of the school’s prior investigations mention the revealing and damaging email exchanges conducted by Nyang’oro and/or Crowder?

-- Why did the university refuse to release the remainder of the Nyang’oro and Crowder emails, even in redacted form?